Are We Really Alone? Scientists Say Alien Civilizations Might Be Invisible to Our Telescopes

Credit: Pixabay

Humans are naturally nosy. We’re always asking, “Are we alone in the universe?” And if there are aliens out there, could we find them by sniffing out their industrial pollution? Spoiler alert: Not likely — unless E.T. has a factory spewing toxic fumes that makes our 20th-century pollution look like a breath of fresh air.

Scientists have been hunting for signs of advanced civilizations for decades, and while we’ve scanned the skies for radio signals and laser pulses, there’s been a new idea in town: What if we look for alien pollution, specifically Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAHs)? These are chemical byproducts of burning fossil fuels — basically the galactic equivalent of catching someone red-handed with an exhaust-spewing car.

But before you start imagining interstellar smog inspectors writing tickets for alien factories, let’s dive into why this approach is trickier than it sounds.

A Brief History of Alien Hunting: More Silence Than Signals

The search for extraterrestrial life isn’t new. Scientists have been trying to make contact since the 1960s — think SETI (Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence) with their giant radio telescopes aimed at the stars. But after decades of listening? Nada. Zilch. It’s like being at a party where no one’s picking up the phone.

So, researchers started shifting gears. Instead of waiting for aliens to call us, why not look for traces of their activities? Water? Sure. Weird light patterns? Definitely. But industrial pollution? Now, that’s an idea only a frustrated scientist would dream up after too many late nights with coffee and no results.

In 2023, a team led by Dwaipayan Dubey decided to explore whether PAHs — hydrocarbons you’d find in Earth’s atmosphere thanks to human industry — could be the key to spotting alien life. After all, if some advanced civilization is burning fossil fuels like there’s no tomorrow, wouldn’t that leave a detectable trace?

Martian Meteorites and the PAH Puzzle

Here’s where it gets interesting. Back in 1996, NASA scientists discovered PAHs in a Martian meteorite found in Antarctica. Headlines went wild — “Life on Mars?” — but the excitement fizzled out faster than a cheap sparkler when skeptics pointed out non-biological explanations. Still, the possibility of detecting hydrocarbons in space lingered.

Dubey’s team wondered: Could these PAHs be floating around in the atmospheres of exoplanets (those distant worlds we keep finding)? If so, maybe we could catch a whiff of alien industry. They even ran simulations using molecules like Naphthalene (yes, like the mothball stuff), Anthracene, and Pyrene. Sounds fancy, right? But hold your horses — the results weren’t exactly promising.

Why Our Telescopes Just Aren’t Up to the Job

Turns out, even with the most powerful Earth-based telescopes — including the upcoming 8-meter Habitable Worlds Observatory — spotting alien pollution is like trying to find a speck of dust on your neighbor’s window… from across town.

Dubey’s simulations showed that current telescopes simply don’t have the resolution or sensitivity to pick up the faint chemical signatures of PAHs in distant atmospheres. It’s like trying to eavesdrop on a whispered conversation from the other side of a crowded room. You might catch a word or two, but good luck getting the whole story.

Even if an alien civilization was belching out PAHs at pre-industrial-revolution levels, we’d still struggle to detect it. The signal-to-noise ratio (basically, how clear the data is) would be too low to make a definitive call.

The Real Takeaway: Not All Scientific Research Ends with a Bang

Here’s the thing about science: Not every experiment ends with a groundbreaking discovery. Sometimes, the answer is just a big, fat “nope.” But that’s valuable too. Knowing what doesn’t work helps steer future research in the right direction.

Dubey’s study is a classic example of this. While the idea of detecting alien pollution sounds cool, it’s currently beyond our technological capabilities. But hey, maybe in a few decades, with more advanced telescopes and better detection methods, we’ll get closer to finding our cosmic neighbors. And who knows? Maybe we’ll stumble upon an alien civilization complaining about their own climate crisis.

The Fun (and Sobering) Part

Let’s get real for a second. If we ever do find signs of alien pollution, what does that say about us? That advanced civilizations, like ours, can’t help but pollute their planets? Kind of depressing, right? Maybe E.T. isn’t phoning home because he’s too busy cleaning up after his industrial mess.

But until then, the search continues. Whether it’s looking for weird light patterns, water, or — in this case — pollution, scientists are determined to answer the age-old question: Are we alone? And honestly, with the way things are going on Earth, maybe the aliens are better off keeping quiet.

The Search Isn’t Over (Yet)

So, could we detect advanced civilizations by their pollution? Probably not with our current tech. But don’t let that discourage you. The universe is a big place, and we’ve only scratched the surface.

In the meantime, let’s keep our own planet clean — because if there are aliens watching us, we’d hate for their first impression to be, “Wow, these Earthlings really need to work on their air quality.”

Now, if only we could get those telescopes to work a little harder…

Susan Kowal
Susan Kowal is a serial entrepreneur, angel investor/advisor, and health enthusiast.